sunil:
thanks much. went to the recommended site. i don't
think you need ti oversimplify it. it is oversimplified in itself though it
could do with a bit of editing.
having seen it, read it i am persuaded that its
propounders live in a world of their own and have a right to do so. i believe
that without intellectual property rights there may have been some ideas.
innovation, technolgy development and progres would have taken another path
altogether and it can be shown that at least in terms of economics as we know
it, it would be a sub-optimal model compared to what we have known. i do not
wish to debate it on this forum for a variety of reasons and would think while
the debate has a place on this forum, it may not be the right place for
allocating majority of its time to free software etc.
you are an infectious speaker and will always sway
people your way. that will not persuade me to go along with the substance
of it though.
thanks much
________________________________
satish jha
cmd, james martin &
co
www.jmcin.compresident, digital
partners india
n-103, panchsheel park,
new delhi - 110 017
v: 649
9384/5; 649 4384/5
f: 649 4380
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Monday, December 16, 2002 5:21
PM
Subject: Re: [bytesforall_readers]
Microsoft to share Windows code withIndia
Dear Satish,
Free Software is not Open Source
Software. Access to code is not the main
issue. Free License implies
Ownership and Control. It is not the recipe of
coke but the ownership of
coke.
Copyrighting is the root cause of the digital divide... here is
an
oversimplification so that you can
understand..
------------------------------------------------------
Before
the concept of Private Property:
No Economic Divide
After the
concept of Private Property:
Land Owners
Landless
Economic
Divide
------------------------------------------------------
Before the
concept of Intellectual Property:-
No Digital Divide
After the
concept of Intellectual Property:
Those with Knowledge
Those without Knowledge
Digital
Divide
------------------------------------------------------
You
will notice this trend in all forms of privatization:- water,
phrases,
gestures, ideas, products etc.
General Public License
transfers ownership of digital assets to the poor.
To use a Marxist phrase
- the means of production in the knowledge economy
will be transfered to
the poor. This is a 'critical' component of any
digital divide
intervention.Without this type of systemic intervention all
other ICT is
merely technology band-aid.
Please see my IIM-B presentation for more
details:
http://www.mahiti.org/events/Event.2002-12-16.3025/view
Thanks,
Sunil
Thanks,
Sunil
=====
Sunil
Abraham [MAHITI]
314/1, 7th Cross, Domlur
Bangalore - 560 071 Karnataka,
INDIA
Ph/Fax: +91 80 5352003. Pager: 9624 279519
sunil@mahiti.org http://www.mahiti.org
To
unsubscribe from this group, send an email
to:
bytesforall_readers-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
Your
use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.