At 4:34 PM +0530 2/1/05, SeekingGyan wrote:

MTNL is testing their broadband services across bombay. I have applied for it but they said it will take atleast 45 days to get a connection as they are still testing in other areas of the city. ... ( me based at borivli )

the engg was not aware about linux support but said they are using all standard and latest stuff ...

has anyone tested it on linux ?

More info on this service is here http://mumbai.mtnl.net.in/internetservices/adsl/triband.html

I am glad that someone on this list points out what should be obvious - that not everyone 'out there' is aware of other operating systems, or even that there are issues around operating systems.

Not that I run a cybercafe or am least interested in running one - but I did think that in a group of people who have an interest in FLOSS there would be some (aside from those who burnt their fingers trying this once before) who would see the value of promoting FLOSSOSes (I love making curious looking acronyms) in different environments.

I have noticed that telco engineers are often completely clueless about personal computing. My direct experience is Reliance, Tata Indicom and MTNL. None knew that there were alternatives to Windows, and that many users of such existed in Mumbai city at least. It took a while for Reliance to create a download for a GNU/Linux compatible dialer for their CDMA fixed wireless service. I don't know if it also works on the Tata service. I do know that asking MTNL for help can be a very frustrating experience.

So next time (and there will be a next time) someone asks for help do look for ways of providing it instead of finding reasons why it should not be given. If you can't think of a way please don't discourage others from trying - by all means let us know of the pitfalls though. That's what an open forum is for.